Blues Acid Test

8 Apr 2022 | 7 comments

In Off The Post

The following article has been written by one of our Trust members.  They are the opinions of that person and not necessarily those of Blues Trust.  Would you like to contribute a discussion point of your own about Birmingham City Football Club?  If so, we would be delighted to hear from you.

Whatever plans are being drawn up by our hierarchy for the summer months regarding on-field playing matters, three issues will surely need to be addressed. Early days of course for George Hall, Jordan James and Jobe Bellingham and their Birmingham City futures but, nevertheless, serious consideration must be given to extending their stays at St Andrew’s. These players are stand-outs as we currently sit, with no lack of interest being shown by potential suitors.

We all know our kamikaze history when it comes to releasing gems at knock down prices, and often prematurely at that. Too many to name but we know the list of regrets. My hope, this time, is that careful and serious consideration will be given to retaining the young talent that we have with a much bigger picture being looked at. Hopefully Craig Gardner and Ian Dutton can have influence along with Lee Bowyer, but I am not that naive to believe it will necessarily be the case.

Merely existing in the second tier is, for many clubs, acceptable and welcomed. But surely we still have more ambition than that? We have a history of glorious highs when securing Premier League status which borders on unparalleled joy. We know what it feels like to be amongst the best, and we dearly want another crack. Keeping the players sought after by others is a key ingredient to achieving success. And that’s not rocket science.

Perhaps the likes of James, Hall and Bellingham will not live up to expectations and disappointment might lie ahead. That’s football. But taking more bad decisions by the early release of players with genuine potential will surely leave us with yet more regret. External reports about Bellingham and James, some seemingly from other managers, are impressive and that’s what I take seriously. Hence my hope that these two remain longer at the club. At seventeen, George Hall is another closely watched talent and there has been a lot of press speculation these past few days that he is being seriously courted by other clubs.

Eleven seasons in the Championship is a long stint for any club although in some cases it is to be expected. But at Blues we have all too regularly shot ourselves in the foot by making poor decisions and letting the very tools needed to achieve success be taken away from us.

These coming summer months will no doubt see much activity on the playing side. Sunday’s victory against West Bromwich Albion has given much needed joy and belief for the remaining six games. Hopefully, the permanent signings of Lyle Taylor and Onel Hernandez will be secured and further encourage all of us for the new season ahead. Above all, however, we must resist approaches for the trio mentioned. Should Nico Gordon continue his admirable progression too, then the likes of Hall, Bellingham and James could prove invaluable investments.

Mitchell Bray


Want to be a full member with voting rights?

We have options for 1 and 2 years at £5 per year.  There is also a 5 year membership for £20 so you get 5 years for the price of 4.  See information and options here.

By making comments:

  • All we ask is that it relates to the Club that we all love. It can inform, question, challenge, criticise even….but it should not be written to threaten and/or cause personal offence.
  • By making comments on the above article, you agree to Blues Trust retaining your email address should we need to make contact with you for admin purposes.   Let us know at if you do not wish us to do this.  We will not give out your email address to any 3rd party sources.

The Trust reserves the right to moderate any comments made (in consultation with the writer) or to deny publication if comments are considered to be inconsistent with the requirements identified above.


  1. pamela allsopp

    Agree totally with article.

  2. Sausage n Egg

    No doubt will leave for a packet of crisps and a pork pie which will be scoffed by someone in the Far East…replaced by loans ,freebies and crocked reserves from other clubs…

  3. tracey tyler

    We will never get anywhere unless we build the club from within.Hernandez and Taylor l would not buy as they are not long term,their ages deem that but by all means have them back on loan for another season and integrate our youngsters,that’s the only way to succeed.

  4. Smithy

    These three players do represent an interesting scenario. All obviously young and potentially an in-house investment for the club. Will they fulfil expectations is the key. Next season will be the test but that boils down as to whether our hierarchy see it that way. Hopefully they will. Depends to a large extent as to the clout that messrs. Gardner, Dutton and Bowyer carry.

  5. Ed Truman

    It will be interesting to see what happens with the three in question. I’m not confident that our owners are interested in the long term though. If half decent offers come in will they reject them?

    Tracey makes a good point and it’s one that I share. But we as supporters would need to change our mindset too to accept steady progression rather than demanding instant success. It does feel that we are moving closer to that now though, with Lee Bowyer still seemingly enjoying widespread support despite another very poor season in terms of results.

    Imagine where we might be now though if our owners had taken the long view when they took over in 2016?

    • Mitchell

      Ed. You are right. Imagining what might have been had we been able to keep those ‘giveaways ‘ gems is too depressing to contemplate.

  6. Bill

    From the 1960’s onward the vast majority of our best players have been home grown so I think this article is spot on.

Share This